Every number has a source. Here is how we check them.
We test the method against decisions that have already been made, publish the results, and say where public filings fall short.
Against what Boards adopted.
Each town rebuilt only from what was public before its vote, then compared with the ordinance its Board passed.
| Town | Our estimate from public filings alone | What the Board adopted | The record |
|---|---|---|---|
Forsyth, IllinoisVillage of 3,490 people | +$5.69a month, 4,000 gallons | +$7.10Ordinance 2025-22, 6–0, September 16, 2025 | The village's own consultant study came to +$5.90. Our estimate missed General Fund repayment and a reserve target; both are now lines the Board sees. Meeting packet |
Readlyn, IowaCity of 845 people | +$8.92a month, 4,000 gallons | +$18.50Ordinance 367, three readings over 126 days | Iowa's filing combines debt and capital with other columns, so the public estimate covered operations only. Council minutes |
Upland, IndianaTown of 3,308 people | HeldThe filed numbers gave 538.70%. That failed our check, so nothing was published. | Ordinances 5-2024 and 6-2024March 19, 2024 | The right answer was to ask the town for its billing and debt records, not to print a number. Council minutes |
Against regulators and consultants.
Given the same inputs a regulator or a consultant used, does the method reach the same answer?
Where public filings fall short.
Said plainly, because a clerk should know before a Board does.
Public filings alone run low
State filings rarely show the capital plan, General Fund repayments or a reserve target. That is why the free summary shows what was filed and names no rate, and why the rate packet waits for your current schedule and a billing summary.
Some states combine funds
Iowa and Illinois often report water and sewer together, and some states fold debt into other columns. The Board summary says when a figure covers both.
When the check fails, nothing is published
In Upland, Indiana the filed numbers produced a 538.70% result. A number like that is a data problem, not an answer, so it was held and the town's records were asked for instead.
Sources on every figure
The Board summary links each year to the filing it came from: the Illinois Comptroller, the Iowa Department of Management, Indiana Gateway, the New York State Comptroller, the Minnesota State Auditor, the Nebraska Auditor and the Kansas Department of Administration, with the federal drinking water record and Census income figures.